Saturday, July 13, 2024

National News: Belize-Guatemala Referendum scheduled for October 6th in limbo


GOB and Opposition rejects Guatemala’s proposal

13 Belize-Guatemala-Referendum-Map-EnglishThe simultaneous Belize-Guatemala Referendum scheduled for October 6th is in limbo after the Republic of Guatemala has made two proposals. These were presented to the Secretary General of the Organization of American States, Jose Miguel Insulza on March 7th and completely diverted from the Special Agreement signed by Belize, Guatemala and the OAS on December 8, 2008. Both the Government of Belize (GOB) and Belize’s main opposition party, People’s United Party (PUP), have rejected Guatemala’s proposals.

13 Wilfred Elrington
Minister of Foreign Affairs, Wilfred ‘Sedi’ Elrington.

The referendum came about as part of the compromise made between Guatemala and Belize, following several rounds of failed negotiations in an effort to peacefully settle Guatemala’s territorial claim over a portion of Belize. Speaking at the sitting of The House of Representative on Thursday March 21st, Belize’s Foreign Affairs Minister Wilfred “Sedi” Elrington disclosed the proposal in addressing the parliament as a matter of national importance. “The first proposal is that they (Guatemala) wanted us (Belize) to amend our referendum legislation so that our legislation will be identical to theirs in terms of the requirements for the referendum to be successful – just a simple majority vote. They said that if we did that, if we amended our legislation to confirm with theirs, they would then be prepared to agree on another date when we could hold simultaneous referenda. They were not prepared to indicate when that date would be and they were not even prepared to give a timeline. The second proposal was that we would go ahead as planned, have our referendum on October 6, and if we had a successful ‘yes’ vote at that referendum, then they would prepared to hold their referendum at a date not later than the end of June 2014,” said Elrington.

Leader of the Opposition, Hon. Francis Fonseca.
Leader of the Opposition, Hon. Francis Fonseca.

First to publicly and flatly reject Guatemala’s proposal was the PUP during a press conference on Monday March 25th. Speaking at the conference, Party Leader of the PUP Hon Francis Fonseca said that Government of the Republic of Guatemala is not acting in good faith and calls on GOB to stand its grounds and reject the proposals. “Guatemala put forward certain proposals that make clear its intention to breach its agreement with Belize to hold simultaneous referenda on October 6, 2013. The People’s United Party (PUP) rejects any proposal which violates the spirit and letter of the Special Agreement signed by Belize and Guatemala in December 2008. Neither option proposed by Guatemala is acceptable. Guatemala’s latest proposals raise serious concerns about its good faith in finding a just and definitive solution of this longstanding claim. The PUP has consistently rejected this unfounded claim, while always remaining supportive of any initiative that would lead to a definitive and just solution. The PUP does not support the holding of any unilateral referendum on October 6, 2013, or on any other date. We do not support the amendment of our national law to reduce our threshold participation in referenda, simply to accommodate Guatemala. The PUP calls on the Government of Belize to remain

Senator Lisa Shoman is no longer part of the negotiating team.
Senator Lisa Shoman is no longer part of the negotiating team.

resolute in maintaining national and international support for our inalienable right to self-determination with full territorial integrity,” said Fonseca. The PUP also announced that Lisa Shoman, who has been on the national negotiation team as the PUP representative, will no longer do so. Shoman has been with the team, first as Ambassador, then as Foreign Minister and now as the opposition’s representative.

The proposals made by Guatemala were sent and discussed in Cabinet on Tuesday March 26th. Following the Cabinet meeting, GOB sent out a press release in which it states that they also reject Guatemala’s proposal. The release explained that GOB will be writing to the OAS to express the country’s official position.“The Government of Belize notes that tremendous efforts over many years and through successive administrations have been spent in finding a negotiated solution that would bring to a definitive end Guatemala’s unfounded claim to Belize, and that the failure of these attempts is what led to the signing of the Special Agreement by Belize, Guatemala and the OAS on 8th December, 2008. That Special Agreement provides for referenda to be held in Belize and in Guatemala simultaneously on the date of 6th October, 2013 and had also been jointly agreed upon by the Parties for the purpose of consulting the respective publics on whether or not the solution should be found in submitting Guatemala’s claim to the International Court of Justice.

Any changes in the Special Agreement or the agreed dates of the referenda must therefore be jointly agreed upon. The Government of Belize is today writing to OAS Secretary General Insulza to inform him that Belize rejects the proposals by Guatemala and to confirm Belize’s continued commitment to abide by the Special Agreement of December 2008, including the holding of simultaneous referenda as agreed on 6th October,” stated the press release.

It is uncertain where the simultaneous referendum scheduled for October 6 stands since Guatemala remains steadfast in the two proposals put forward. Once Belize has submitted its position in writing to the OAS, it is expected that the hemispheric organization will make a statement on the issue.

Read more


Please help support Local Journalism in Belize

For the first time in the history of the island's community newspaper, The San Pedro Sun is appealing to their thousands of readers to help support the paper during the COVID-19 pandemic. Since 1991 we have tirelessly provided vital local and national news. Now, more than ever, our community depends on us for trustworthy reporting, but our hard work comes with a cost. We need your support to keep delivering the news you rely on each and every day. Every reader contribution, however big or small, is so valuable. Please support us by making a contribution.

Local News