ACCSD lobbies stakeholders for support against Cayo Rosario Development

Saturday, December 1st, 2018

The Board of Directors for the Ambergris Caye Citizens for Sustainable Development (ACCSD) held an informative luncheon on Tuesday, November 27th for key tourism and business stakeholders on the island. Hosted by Matachica Resort, more than a dozen individuals were updated on the progress ACCSD is making in preventing the controversial development of Cayo Rosario located within the Hol Chan Marine Reserve.
First to speak was ACCSD Board member and President of the San Pedro Tour Guide Association Billy Leslie, who reviewed the history of the Hol Chan Marine Reserve and the part ACCSD played in expanding the reserve in 2015. “We saw that this area on the leeward side of the island, the shoals, the mangrove islands, and bajos were essential to the health of the Hol Chan ecosystem and an important area for the fly-fishing industry. We worked closely with other agencies on the island along with local and national government to make it happen. Our goal was to prevent unsustainable developments like the one approved for Cayo Rosario from ever happening. This sensitive area cannot support the proposed over-the-water structures, dredging, mangrove removal, and sewage system without irreparable damage,” he stated.
Board member and marine biologist Miguel Alamilla was next to elaborate on the flaws in the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) that was contracted by the developer and problems within the entire National Environmental Appraisal Committee (NEAC) approval process. “Developers hire their own accessor to conduct their EIA, so naturally they will error on the side of the developer. In the case of Cayo Rosario, improper methodology was used along with inaccurate observations such as no sign of fish or wildlife in the area. In approving the EIA, NEAC failed to consider several laws and regulations, such as the fact that the developer only held one of the two public hearings required, and the illegal use/development of ‘Queens Land’ to name a few,” explained Alamilla.
Elito Arceo, Board member and co-founder of ACCSD emphasized the impact the approval of such a development can have. He commented, “Is this the message we want to send, that it is ok to irresponsibly develop within a marine reserve? If we allow for this development to proceed what is next? There are other little mangrove islands throughout the reserve, if this happens will they all be exploited to this extent?”
ACCSD Chairwoman Rebecca Arceo explained where the organization is at regarding litigation and how they plan to proceed. “We have retained legal defense and argue that the government has not complied with many of their own laws. It is our understanding that the developer has been pre-selling this project for the last three years and our first step is to file for an injunction to prevent any sort of construction to begin. This will be filed by mid-December,” she explained. “We are also working on an education campaign…the community needs to understand how important the health and protection of the Hol Chan Marine Reserve is to our tourism dollar and island economy. This affects each and every one of us. We are planning a big rally and petition signing as well, our local and government leaders need to see how many people agree with protecting the reserve. We are also working on a fundraising event early next year.”
Litigation comes with a price, and according to ACCSD Treasurer and co-chair Chis Beaumont, the organization has already paid $8k in legal fees with funding donations from Yellow Dog Flyfishing Adventures, Tres Pescado Fishing Tournament, El Pescador Lodge and other individuals, businesses and organizations. It is estimated that legal fees could exceed $30k.
During the meeting, ACCSD lobbied the group for their support in challenging this detrimental development. “We hope that with this information we can count on you and your businesses to help us in future endeavors to educate the community and appeal for funding,” concluded Chairwoman Arceo. With an enthusiastic show of hands, all attendees agreed to join the important cause.
The Cayo Rosario development was approved by NEAC in July 2018, and calls for 54 over-the-water structures, 50 more partially over-the-water and land structures, two kilometers of submarine sewage trench and the dredging of 55,000 cubic meters of sand for land creation from within the extension of the Hol Chan Marine Reserve. The mangrove caye is just over six acres in size. Organizations that have joined ACCSD in opposition to the project include the San Pedro Tour Guide Association, San Pedro Tour Operator Association, San Pedro Mayor Daniel Guerrero, OCEANA Belize, World Wildlife Fund, Belize Tourism Industry, MarAlliance, San Pedro Businesses Association, Hoteliers, Flyfishing Operators and Lodges, Belize Federation of Fishers, international organizations and many more.
The mission of ACCSD is to promote sustainable development; to protect and enhance our natural resources without compromising the livelihood of this and future generations. For more information and how you can support the Cayo Rosario campaign please visit


Please help support Local Journalism in Belize

For the first time in the history of the island's community newspaper, The San Pedro Sun is appealing to their thousands of readers to help support the paper during the COVID-19 pandemic. Since 1991 we have tirelessly provided vital local and national news. Now, more than ever, our community depends on us for trustworthy reporting, but our hard work comes with a cost. We need your support to keep delivering the news you rely on each and every day. Every reader contribution, however big or small, is so valuable. Please support us by making a contribution.

Click to Donate

Follow The San Pedro Sun News on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook. Stay updated via RSS

Leave a Reply

Comments are closed on this post.