Tuesday, July 23, 2024

2016 Healthy Reefs Report Card: Belize Barrier Reef ‘endangered’


On Thursday, July 7th, various entities dedicated to the important work of preserving and protecting Belize’s natural heritage presented the Belize Barrier Reef scorecard for 2016. The purpose of the evaluation is to get Belize’s Reef System off the World Heritage Site’s endangered category. The reef system has been on that list since 2009, and according to the results this year much more needs to be done before its removal from the vulnerable category.29 Barrier Reef Report Card
The Belize Barrier Reef runs parallel to the coast of Belize for about 185 miles and is responsible for 15% of the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP). However, this great valuable natural resource is in danger. According to Valentino Shal from the World Wildlife Fund they are looking at all that needs to be done in order to get the Barrier Reef off the endangered list, while at the same time ensuring that it is a healthy and functioning resource. “The indicators of this score card are based on the exact same indicators that are included in the desired state of conservation report that we the World Heritage Committee and The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) gave to the government,” said Shal. He added that unless the government addresses the issues highlighted in the indicators, the reef will continue to be considered vulnerable.
The report card details how effective the Government of Belize (GOB) has been in implementing policies and actions to address the issue. The scores are divided into three points. A score of 1 indicates major concerns; a score of 2 indicates some concerns and 3 means good progress. In the report card, none of the six indicators given to GOB received a score of 3. But five of the six received a score of 2. This is good news to some extent as it indicated that there has been some progress.
The indicators that received a score of two were Offshore Oil Drilling, Mangrove Conservation, Costal development and Tourism, Fisheries and Wold Heritage Value. Meanwhile the worst score was regarding Environmental Regulation, which is of major concern.
Janelle Chanona, Vice President of Oceana Belize spoke about the threats of the first indicator and why it is important to get a better score on it. “Roughly 85% of our exclusive economic zone and our territorial waters would be vulnerable to offshore oil activity if the moratorium was ever lifted,” said Chanona. “This is the key takeaway for where we are on oil, that there is pressing need for us to get the moratorium formalized for the government to outline the specific conditions under which that moratorium would be lifted. That is where the concerns are beginning to arise.”
According to Roberto Pott, Country Coordinator for Healthy Reefs, the unregulated removal of mangroves from sensitive zones is also an issue. “We have to be able to catalogue and recognize the areas that are sensitive in terms of our fishing industry, our tourism industry, and in terms of shoreline protection,” said Pott. “There is little to no incentive for development to maintain mangroves intact and so we need to revisit that and see how we can make improvements.”
Belize Audubon Society representative, Executive Director Amanda Burgos-Acosta, says that one of the reasons why the reef system is still considered in great danger is due to the little enforcement on development within the World Heritage Site. “It will be crucial to have an Act or Bill that can guide development. That was one of the triggers that actually led to our inscription on the endangered list,” said Burgos-Acosta.
Even with the negative score, the Environmental Protection Act was applauded for having contributed to some of the progress so far. Candy Gonzalez, President of the Belize Institute of Environment Law and Policy said that improvement in the future is possible if the Act is properly enforced. “Until these things are put into law we can see major changes. But if they remain as words then we will not move forward and that is the problem with a lot of the things called Cabinet decisions and Memorandums,” said Gonzalez. “They can be made in a day and they can be changed in a day.”
At the end of the presentations, the organizers and presenters of the scorecard indicated that in order for the Belize Barrier Reef report to improve, all Belizeans need to do their part. It is everyone’s job to ensure that future generations benefit from this valuable natural resource. They hope that next year the results are opposite to the current ones.
The decision to keep the Belize Barrier Reef on the endangered list was made even more official on Tuesday, July 12th during a United Nation (UN) session in Istanbul, Turkey where representatives from 192 countries attended. The UN urged protection for World Heritage Sites and thus, the Belize Barrier Reef will remain to be on the list of World Heritage Sites in danger.
The decision was taken after the imminent threats of oil exploration, damaging coastal construction and pollution. At the meeting, Belize was recognized for its commitments to protect the reef by promising to ban oil exploration in the World Heritage Site. However, they asked that such promises be enacted in law. “We are moving in the right direction with this decision, but it’s a long road to ensure that both the reef and the people who rely on it are protected into the future,” said Nadia Bood, a World Wide Fund for Nature- Belize Reef Scientist.
She also stated that WWF will welcome an expert monitoring mission by the end of 2016 to assess the government’s progress. “An oil spill anywhere within Belize’s waters would have a devastating effect on the reef and on the national economy,” she said. “We need to prioritize the reef’s long-term value, rather than put at risk its sustainable development potential.”
Last year, the government of Belize announced a policy intended to ban offshore oil exploration within the reef system and one kilometre buffer zone. This effectively should result in a total of 2,117 KM2 being protected, but leaves 85% of the country’s waters open to future oil extraction. WWF calls for a full ban on all offshore oil exploration and extraction to protect the reef and the livelihoods of 190,000 people which is almost half of the population of Belize who depend on it to make a living.
A report produced for WWF by Dalberg Global Development earlier this year found that nearly half of all natural World Heritage sites are threatened by harmful industrial activities, such as oil and gas exploration, mining, large- scale infrastructure projects and industrial-scale logging or fishing. Some of these can be related to Belize and WWF argues that governments should ensure that no harmful industrial activities are permitted in World Heritage sites or in areas that could negatively affect them.

Read more


Please help support Local Journalism in Belize

For the first time in the history of the island's community newspaper, The San Pedro Sun is appealing to their thousands of readers to help support the paper during the COVID-19 pandemic. Since 1991 we have tirelessly provided vital local and national news. Now, more than ever, our community depends on us for trustworthy reporting, but our hard work comes with a cost. We need your support to keep delivering the news you rely on each and every day. Every reader contribution, however big or small, is so valuable. Please support us by making a contribution.

Local News